In a dimly lit room on the eve of the Ninth of Av, Rabbi Menachem Friedman sits down with his son Eli to explore the crushing weight of Jewish history, the meaning of mourning, and why the saddest day of the year holds the secret to our greatest hope.
The room was noticeably quieter than usual. There was no music playing, no drinks on the table, and the chairs had been pushed aside so that Rabbi Friedman and his son Eli were seated on low stools.
Eli looked down at the floor for a moment before speaking, his voice softer than usual. "Tatte, we always talk about joy, about celebration, about how HaShem wants us to feel at home in this world. Then comes Tisha B'Av, the saddest and most tragic day of the whole year. When you look at the sheer weight of what happened on the Ninth of Av, it’s almost overwhelming. How do you even begin to process it?"
Rabbi Friedman nodded slowly, his expression deeply serious yet steady. "You don't try to minimize it, Eli. You look at it straight on. Tisha B'Av is a day of fasting and mourning because it carries the collective heartbreak of our entire history. First, we mourn the destruction of the First Temple in 586 B.C.E., when the Babylonians ransacked it and burnt it to the ground. Then, on the exact same date, the destruction of the Second Temple in 70 C.E. by the Romans."
"And it wasn't just a religious loss," Eli added quietly. "It meant the end of the First and Second Jewish Commonwealths, and the exile of the Jewish people from our very own land."
"Exactly," Rabbi Friedman replied. "And the Temple is still not restored, a loss that feels even sharper when we look at the Holy Temple Mount today, where a major Islamic shrine was built in 691 C.E. where the Beis HaMikdash once stood. Yet Tisha B'Av didn't stop there. It became the focal point for every tragedy that followed in exile. In 1492, Spain issued its decree on this very day, expelling all Jews with no alternative other than death or conversion to Christianity. Every year, Tisha B'Av gives us a day to remember and never forget every wave of cruelty, torture, and oppression, reaching its horrific climax in the Holocaust of 1939 to 1945, where a third of all Jewish people, men, women, and children, were systematically murdered after unimaginable suffering."
Eli took a slow breath, absorbing the gravity of the timeline. "And the way we lead up to this day pulls us into that grief step by step."
"Because you can't just drop into mourning out of nowhere," his father explained. "Tisha B'Av is the peak of a three-week period of semi-mourning that starts on the seventeenth of Tammuz, the minor fast marking the day the Babylonians first breached the walls of Jerusalem. For those Three Weeks, we don't hold weddings or celebrations with music. Then, when the month of Av begins, the Nine Days start, and the mourning intensifies. We don't eat meat or drink wine except on Shabbos, and buying new clothes waits until after Tisha B'Av."
"And then comes the fast itself," Eli said, looking around the stripped-down room. "From before sundown on the eighth of Av until nightfall the next day, it’s a total fast just like Yom Kippur. Even studying Torah is restricted, because Torah brings joy."
"Think about that," Rabbi Friedman said, leaning forward slightly. "We even pause Torah study. When evening services begin, the paroches, the curtain on the Ark, is removed or replaced with something plain, and in some communities the Ark is draped in black. We sit on the ground or on low stools without wearing Tallis or Tefillin in the morning. We read Megillas Eichah, the Book of Lamentations, in a broken, mournful melody at night and again in the morning, followed by Kinos, the elegies of mourning."
Eli looked at his father thoughtfully. "To an outsider, Tatte, sitting on the floor weeping over events from two thousand years ago might look like living in the past. Why does HaShem want us to feel this pain so rawly?"
Menachem Friedman's eyes held a strong conviction. "Because you only mourn for something you still expect to get back. If you give up on someone, you move on. You stop crying. The fact that we sit on the floor every Tisha B'Av proves that we have never accepted golus as normal. We refuse to get comfortable without HaShem’s home in Jerusalem."
"So the mourning itself is an act of faith," Eli said softly.
"It is the purest act of faith," his father nodded. "As the Rebbe always taught us, Tisha B'Av isn't just about looking backward at destruction - it is about demanding the rebuilding. The Sages teach that Moshiach is born on Tisha B'Av. When we mourn together, when we feel the absence of the Beis HaMikdash and care deeply for one another, we turn the saddest day of the year into the greatest celebration, the day the Third Beis HaMikdash is built, speedily in our days."
Eli sat quietly for a moment, the heaviness in the room suddenly feeling less like despair and more like an unbreakable emunah to see Yerushalayim rebuilt and the Beis HaMikdash restored, with the coming of Moshiach speedily in our days. Omeyn.